A Study of the Changes of Mental Stress among Male Urban Residents: Based on Results of a 16-Year Follow-up Survey in Three Provincial Capitals in China
Zhang Weifang1,2, Chen Leyi1,2, Wang Huihui1,2, Yang Tingzhong3
1.Affiliated Hospital of Stomatology, Zhejiang University School of Medicine, Hangzhou 310006, China 2.Key Laboratory of Oral Biomedical Research of Zhejiang Province, Hangzhou 310006, China 3.Women’s Hospital, School of Medicine, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310006, China
Abstract：Social theory for stress regards mental stress as a social phenomenon, and emphasizes the understanding and dealings with stress through the social system. In fact, mental stress reflects the function of the social system. The study aims at examining the status of the social system in a 16-year follow-up observation of mental stress among urban residents in three provincial capitals in China. The information that the study obtains from changes in the China social system will help decision-makers consider the solution and improvement of the social systemic problems.Data were collected in three provinces’ capital cities, Taiyuan, Hangzhou, and Guangzhou, which are in different geographical areas in China. The surveys were conducted in 2001, 2008, and 2016 respectively. Participants were recruited through a multi-stage stratified sampling process. Mental stress was assessed using the Perceived Stress Scale (Chinese version) (CPSS). High mental stress (HMS) prevalence levels and associated 95% confidence intervals (CI) were estimated. All factors are adjusted for the city and demographic characteristics.In 2001, 1,597 valid questionnaires were obtained, with an effective rate of 96.3%. In 2008, 1,345 valid questionnaires were obtained, with an effective rate of 92.8%. In 2016, 2,628 valid questionnaires were obtained, with an effective rate of 95.8%. The results show no statistically significant change in the status over the observation period. The adjusted HMS prevalence for the combined samples of urban male residents was 42.9 % (95%CI: 36.3%, 49.3%) in 2001, 43.7% (95%CI: 36.4%, 51.5%) in 2008, and 31.6% (95%CI: 25.1%, 38.1%) in 2016. This finding is not consistent with social and economic growth trends over the same period and deviates from the laws of social economics about mental stress, which may reflect the fact that many aspects of increasing mental stress have emerged in the social transition period. This study shows that currently more than one-third of urban male residents have high mental stress, which indicates the seriousness of mental problems among urban residents in China. The defects and imperfections in the current social system should be taken seriously.Although there were no significant changes in the total trend of stress during the observation period, the social structure of stress changed. Significant differences were observed in the changes of stress among different social classes of people. HMS prevalence declined in some social strata while remaining high among the middle-aged, most educated, professional, and administrative staff. The current situation and changes in the pressure on middle-aged professionals do not conform to the law of the relationship between social and economic pressures, suggesting that there may be deviations in the past social policies for them. HMS prevalence also remained high among urban residents in Taiyuan but declined among counterparts in Hangzhou and Guangzhou. Socioeconomic theory and empirical researches have confirmed that the material and spiritual advantages of people’s socioeconomic status have the effect of reducing mental stress. The high mental stress of middle-aged professionals deviates from this association. This indicates that there may be flaws in the policies, confirming the fact that the situation in the real world is unavoidable and they face various stress and uncertainty. The prominent feature of a modern society is that the pace of the society is accelerated and social competition is fierce, which leads to increased mental problems in people’s survival. Middle-aged professionals are the main force of production in the modern society. They need to stand alone in a complex and changeable world and undertake heavy tasks, which put them in a state of severe stress.This study reflects the pulse of social changes and accompanying issues during the past 16 years. In the long run, the continuous high stress among the population is likely to have a very adverse impact on the society. Mental stress is an inevitable phenomenon accompanied by the development of the modern society. If we do not take decisive measures to prevent a severe stress epidemic in society, the consequences for the society and the health of the population will be seriously adverse. We believe that “source governing” is the key to the problem. It is necessary to explore its social mechanism from the perspective of a social theory for stress, analyze the problems existing in the social system, and find out solutions to control over mental stress problems. It underscores the importance for decision-makers to pay attention to the problems existing in the social system and consider the design and implementation of targeted social system interventions. It is imperative to improve the current system, overcome social disadvantages, eliminate social inequality of mental stress, establish a fair social competition mechanism, and increase social well-being to reduce the stress on our residents.
章伟芳, 陈乐怡, 王慧慧, 杨廷忠. 我国城市男性居民心理压力变化研究[J]. 浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2023, 53(6): 103-115.
Zhang Weifang, Chen Leyi, Wang Huihui, Yang Tingzhong. A Study of the Changes of Mental Stress among Male Urban Residents: Based on Results of a 16-Year Follow-up Survey in Three Provincial Capitals in China. JOURNAL OF ZHEJIANG UNIVERSITY, 2023, 53(6): 103-115.
1 杨廷忠、刘晓林： 《心理压力的公共卫生问题与预防对策》，《中华预防医学杂志》2003年第3期，第207-209页。 2 杨廷忠、黄汉腾： 《社会转型中城市居民心理压力的流行病学研究》，《中华流行病学杂志》2003年第9期，第760-764页。 3 Wu D.， Yu L. & Yang T. et al.， “The impacts of uncertainty stress on mental disorders of Chinese college students： evidence from a nationwide study，” Frontiers in Psychology， Vol. 11， No. 243 （2020）， pp. 1-9. 4 Schonfeld I. S.， Bianchi R. & Luehring-Jones P.， “Consequences of job stress for the mental health of teachers，” in McIntyre T.， McIntyre S. & Francis D. （eds.）， Educator Stress： An Occupational Health Perspective， vol. 1， Berlin： Springer， 2017， pp. 55-75. 5 杨廷忠、章伟芳、彭嗣惠： 《社会压力理论的构建与验证》，《浙江大学学报（人文社会科学版）》2022年第10期，第61-68页。 6 Singh A. & Gosain N.， Human Behaviour at Work， New Deli： Psycho Information Technologies， 2019. 7 Charlson F. J.， Baxter A. J. & Cheng H. G. et al.， “The burden of mental， neurological， and substance use disorders in China and India： a systematic analysis of community representative epidemiological studies，” The Lancet， Vol. 388， No. 10042 （2016）， pp. 376-389. 8 Huang Y.， Wang Y. & Wang H. et al.， “Prevalence of mental disorders in China： a cross-sectional epidemiological study，” The Lancet Psychiatry， Vol. 6， No. 3 （2019）， pp. 211-224. 9 Phillips M. R.， Zhang J. & Shi Q. et al.， “Prevalence， treatment， and associated disability of mental disorders in four provinces in China during 2001-05： an epidemiological survey，” The Lancet， Vol. 373， No. 9680 （2009）， pp. 2041-2053. 10 Lynch J. & Kaplan G.， Socioeconomic Position， New York： Oxford University Press， 2000. 11 Berkman L. F. & Kawachi I.， Social Epidemiology， New York： Oxford University Press， 2000. 12 杨廷忠： 《个体认知与社会影响跨层次理论的构建研究》，《社会科学研究前沿》2023年第1期，第33-37页。 13 陆学艺、景天魁： 《转型中的中国社会》，哈尔滨：黑龙江人民出版社，1994年。 14 国家统计局： 《改革开放40年中国GDP增长33.5倍 年均增长9.5%》，2018年8月27日，http：//www.ce.cn/xwzx/gnsz/gdxw/201808/27/t20180827_30135209.shtml，2023年3月6日。 15 国家统计局： 《第七次全国人口普查公报》，2021年5月11日，https：//www.gov.cn/guoqing/2021-05/13/content_5606149.htm，2023年3月6日。 16 中华人民共和国教育部： 《数说“教育这十年”》，2022年9月27日，http：//www.moe.gov.cn/fbh/live/2022/54875/sfcl/202209/t20220927_665124.html，2023年3月2日。 17 陆学艺： 《当代中国社会阶层研究报告》，北京：社会科学文献出版社，2002年。 18 Chen B. & Feng Y.， “Determinants of economic growth in China： private enterprise， education， and openness，” China Economic Review， Vol. 11， No. 1 （2001）， pp. 1-15. 19 Chen H.， “Development of financial intermediation and economic growth： the Chinese experience，” China Economic Review， Vol. 17， No. 4 （2006）， pp. 347-362. 20 程永宏： 《改革以来全国总体基尼系数的演变及其城乡分解》，《中国社会科学》2007年第4期，第45-60页。 21 Wang H.， Yang X. Y. & Yang T. et al.， “Socioeconomic inequalities and mental stress in individual and regional level： a twenty one cities study in China，” International Journal for Equity in Health， Vol. 14， No. 25 （2015）， http：//dx.doi.org/10.1186/s12939-015-0152-4. 22 Markwick A.， Ansari Z. & Sullivan M. et al.， “Inequalities in the social determinants of health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People： a cross-sectional population-based study in the Australian state of Victoria，” International Journal for Equity in Health， Vol. 13 （2014）， pp. 1-12. 23 杨廷忠： 《健康研究：社会行为理论与方法》，北京：人民卫生出版社，2018年。 24 Shea B. M.， “Socioeconomic status and stress，” in Cockerham C.， Dingwall R. & Quah S. （eds.）， The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Health， Illness， Behavior， and Society， Hoboken： John Wiley & Sons， 2014， pp. 2245-2248. 25 Baum A.， Garofalo J. P. & Yali A. M.， “Socioeconomic status and chronic stress： does stress account for SES effects on health？” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences， Vol. 896， No. 1 （1999）， pp. 131-144. 26 Schoon I. & Henseke G.， “Social inequalities in young people’s mental distress during the COVID-19 pandemic： do psychosocial resource factors matter？” Frontiers in Public Health， Vol. 10 （2022）， pp. 820-270. 27 Yang T.， Yang X.Y. & Yu L. et al.， “Individual and regional association between socioeconomic status and uncertainty stress， and life stress： a representative nationwide study of China，” International Journal for Equity in Health， Vol. 16， No. 1 （2017）， pp. 1-8. 28 Zhou X.， “Economic transformation and income inequality in urban China： evidence from panel data，” American Journal of Sociology， Vol. 105， No. 4 （2000）， pp. 1135-1174. 29 Meng M.， “Economic restructuring and income inequality in urban China，” Review of Income and Wealth， Vol. 50， No. 3 （2004）， pp. 357-379. 30 Gratz K. L.， “Risk factors for and functions of deliberate self-harm： an empirical and conceptual review，” Clinical Psychology： Science and Practice， Vol. 10， No. 2 （2003）， pp. 192-205. 31 Yang T.， Jiang S. & Yu L. et al.， “Life stress， uncertainty stress and self-reported illness： a representative nationwide study of Chinese students，” Journal of Public Health， Vol. 26， No. 2 （2018）， pp. 205-209. 32 Peng S.， Yang X. Y. & Yang T. et al.， “Uncertainty stress， and its impact on disease fear and prevention behavior during the COVID-19 epidemic in China： a panel study，” American Journal of Health Behavior， Vol. 45， No. 2 （2021）， pp. 334-341. 33 Yang X. Y.， Hu A. & Schieman S.， “Relative deprivation in context： how contextual status homogeneity shapes the relationship between disadvantaged social status and health，” Social Science Research， Vol. 81 （2019）， pp. 157-169. 34 Yang X. Y.， “Class status and social mobility on tobacco smoking in post-reform China between 1991 and 2011，” Nicotine and Tobacco Research， Vol. 22， No. 12 （2020）， pp. 2188-2195. 35 杨廷忠： 《社会结构行为理论及跨层次形式》，2023年5月24日，https：//chinaxiv.org/abs/202305.00222V1，2023年6月4日。 36 Bird C. E. & Rieker P. P.， Gender and Health： The Effects of Constrained Choices and Social Policies， New York： Cambridge University Press， 2008. 37 太原市统计局： 《2022年太原市经济运行情况新闻发布稿》，2023年1月31日，https：//stats.taiyuan.gov.cn/sjjd/20230131/30018174.html，2023年3月6日。 38 杭州市人民政府： 《2022年杭州经济运行情况》，2023年1月28日，http：//drc.hangzhou.gov.cn/art/2023/1/28/art_1568489_58906070.html，2023年3月6日。 39 广州市统计局： 《2022年广州经济运行情况》，2023年1月20日，https：//gz.gov.cn/zwgk/sjfb/tjfx/content/post_8775314.html，2023年3月2日。 40 Yang T.， Rockett I. R. H. & Yang X. et al.， “Patterns and correlates of stress among rural Chinese males： a four-region study，” Public Health， Vol. 123， No. 10 （2009）， pp. 694-698. 41 Yang Y.， Yang X. Y. & Yang T. et al.， “Social deprivation and secondhand smoke exposure among urban male residents： a nationwide study in China，” Tobacco Induced Diseases， Vol. 19， No. 21 （2021）， pp. 1-9. 42 王济川、谢海义、姜宝法： 《多层统计分析模型——方法与应用》，北京：高等教育出版社，2008年。 43 国家统计局编： 《中国统计年鉴（2018年）》，北京：中国统计出版社，2018年。 44 World Health Organization， “Death and DALY estimates for 2004 by cause for countries： persons， all ages by country，” 2009-01-01， https：//www.researchgate.net/publication/271524820_Death_and_DALY_Estimates_for_2004_by_Cause_for_countries_Persons_all_ages_by_country， 2023-03-02. 45 Barrett A. E. & Turner R. J.， “Family structure and mental health： the mediating effects of socioeconomic status， family process， and social stress，” Journal of Health and Social Behavior， Vol. 46， No. 2 （2005）， pp. 156-169. 46 Sorokin P. A.， Social and Cultural Mobility， New York： Free Press， 1959. 47 Pajo E.， International Migration， Social Demotion， and Imagined Advancement： An Ethnography of Socioglobal Mobility， Berlin： Springer， 2007. 48 国家统计局城市社会经济调查司编： 《中国城市统计年鉴（2008）》，北京：中国统计出版社，2009年。
2023, Vol. 53 
