Stage Outsourcing Behavior in Rice Production under Rapid Transformation: An Empirical Study Based on Evidences from Rice Farmers in Jiangxi Province
Wang Jianying1, Huang Zuhui2, Kevin Z. Chen3, Thomas Reardon4, Jin Ling5
1.College of Economics, Zhejiang University of Finance & Economics, Hangzhou 310018, China;
2.China Academy for Rural Development, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310058, China;
3.International Food and Policy Research Institute, Washington D.C. 20006-1002, U.S.A.;
4.Department of Agricultural, Food and Resource Economics, Michigan State University, East Lancing 48823, U.S.A.;
5.School of Economics and Management, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan 430070, China
Stage outsourcing behavior of rice producers has become increasingly important because of the rapid transformation of China’s countryside,which includes the rapid development of land rental markets, village labor out-migration and use of farm machines. However, few studies have addressed this issue using a theoretical framework. We set out to fill this gap in the literature by developing a theoretical model that integrates determinants of rice farmers’ outsourcing behavior and number of rice growing stages outsourced, and use a Probit model and a Poisson model to estimate them at both the growing season-level and the household-level, respectively. Moreover, a multivariate probit model is used to determine whether outsourcing decisions are made at different stages in isolation or if they are related. In particular, we use 2011 data from 325 rice farmers in Jiangxi Province and 2007 data from 307 rice farmers from the same group. The survey covered 8 rice-growing stages over multiple growing seasons. Descriptive and regression results show that (1) stage outsourcing in rice production is a common phenomenon, especially for labor-intensive stages, with technology-intensive stages still generally involving on family labor. (2) Rice farmers with different production scales utilize different outsourcing modes with small-scale rice farmers typically outsourcing labor-intensive stages, while large-scale rice farmers exhibit a higher proportion of technology-intensive stage outsourcing. (3) Focusing on the season-level instead of on the household-level improves rice production outsourcing research by preventing the loss of useful information through the process of data aggregation, which often produces inaccurate results. (4) Multivariate probit model regression results show that outsourcing decisions made at different rice production stages are related, and are not made in isolation. (5) Different factors affect outsourcing decisions at different kind of rice production stages. In general, not only growing non-farm employment opportunities and rising non-farm incomes facilitate rice farmer stage outsourcing, but also reducing outsourcing prices will increase the proportion of outsourcing taking place at each rice production stage. In light of these findings, it is suggested that specialized rice farmers and farmers’ cooperative organizations be gradually developed and encouraged to provide organized services related to seedlings provision and pests and diseases control, etc. As for the traditional and wasteful modes of paddy drying, policy financing and purchasing subsidies should be provided to large rice farmers, mills, and farmers’ cooperatives for dryer purchase, so as to raise the mechanization level in the drying stage of rice production, as well as to safeguard food safety and quality.
王建英 黄祖辉 陈志钢 [美]托马斯·里尔登 金铃. 水稻生产环节外包决策实证研究——基于江西省稻农水稻种植数据的研究[J]. 浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2018, 4(2): 33-54.
Wang Jianying, Huang Zuhui, Kevin Z. Chen, Thomas Reardon, Jin Ling. Stage Outsourcing Behavior in Rice Production under Rapid Transformation: An Empirical Study Based on Evidences from Rice Farmers in Jiangxi Province. JOURNAL OF ZHEJIANG UNIVERSITY, 2018, 4(2): 33-54.
[1] de Brauw A., Huang J. & Zhang L. et al.,″The Feminization of Agricultural with Chinese Characteristics,″ The Journal of Development Studies, Vol.49, No, 5(2013), pp.689-704. [2] Yu B., Liu F.& You L.,″Dynamic Agricultural Supply Response under Economic Transformation: A Case Study of Henan, China,″ American Journal of Agricultural Economics,Vol.94.2(2012), pp.370-376. [3] Cai F.& Wang M.,″A Counterfactual Analysis on Unlimited Surplus Labor in Rural China,″ China & World Economy,Vol.16.1(2008), pp.51-65. [4] 陈超、黄宏伟:《基于角色分化视角的稻农生产环节外包行为研究——来自江苏省三县(市)的调查》,《经济问题》,2012年第9期, 第87-92页. [Chen Chao & Huang Hongwei,″A Study Based on the Role Differentiation Perspective of Rice Farmers in the Production Processes Outsourcing Behavior: A Survey in Three Counties of Jiangsu Province,″Economic Issues,No.9(2012), pp.87-92.] [5] 廖西元、申红芳、王志刚:《中国特色农业规模经营“三步走”战略——从“生产环节流转”到“经营权流转”再到“承包权流转”》,《农业经济问题》,2011年第12期, 第15-22页. [Liao Xiyuan, Shen Hongfang & Wang Zhigang,″'Three-step' Strategy Promoting Agriculture Scale Management with Chinese Characteristics,″Issues in Agricultural Economy,No.12(2011), pp.15-22.] [6] 王志刚、申红芳、廖西元:《农业规模经营:从生产环节外包开始——以水稻为例》,《中国农村经济》,2011年第9期, 第4-12页. [Wang Zhigang, Shen Hongfang & Liao Xiyuan,″Agricultural Scale Operation: Evidences from Rice Stage Outsourcing,″Chinese Rural Economy,No.9(2011), pp4-12.] [7] 纪月清、钟甫宁:《非农就业与农户农机服务利用》,《南京农业大学学报(社会科学版)》,2013年第5期, 第47-52页. [Ji Yueqing & Zhong Funing,″Non-farm Employment and the Input of Machinery Service,″Journal of Nanjing Agricultural University(Social Science Edition), No.5(2013), pp.47-52.] [8] Yang J., Huang Z.& Zhang X. et al.,″The Rapid Rise of Cross-regional Agricultural Mechanization Services in China,″ American Journal of Agricultural Economics,Vol.95, No.5(2013), pp.1245-1251. [9] Picazo-Tadeo A.J. & Reig-Martinez E.,″Outsourcing and Efficiency: The Case of Spanish Citrus Farming,″ Agricultural Economics, Vol.35, No.2(2006), pp.213-222. [10] 陈超、李寅秋、廖西元:《水稻生产环节外包的生产率效应分析——基于江苏省三县的面板数据》,《中国农村经济》,2012年第2期, 第86-96页. [Chen Chao, Li Yinqiu & Liao Xiyuan,″Productivity Effect Analysis of Rice Production Stage Outsourcing: Evidences Based on Panel Data of Three Counties in Jiangsu Province,″Chinese Rural Economy,No.2(2012), pp.86-96.] [11] Carter M.,″Identification of the Inverse Relationship between Farm Size and Productivity: An Empirical Analysis of Peasant Agricultural Production,″ Oxford Economic Papers,Vol.36, No.1(1984), pp.131-145. [12] Jacoby H.,″Shadow Wages and Peasant Family Labor Supply: An Econometric Application to the Peruvian Sierra,″ The Review of Economic Studies,Vol.60.4(1993), pp.903-921. [13] C.B.Barrett,″On Price Risk and the Inverse Farm Size-productivity Relationship,″ Journal of Development Economics,Vol.51.2(1996), pp.193-215. [14] C.Udry,″Gender, Agricultural Productivity and the Theory of the Household,″ Journal of Political Economy,Vol.104.5(1996), pp.1010-1046. [15] Benjamin D.,″Household Composition, Labor Markets, and Labor Demand: Testing for Separation in Agricultural Household Models,″ Econometrica,Vol.60, No.2(1992), pp.287-322. [16] Pitt M.& Rosenzweig M.,″Agricultural Prices, Food Consumption and the Health and Productivity of Indonesian Farmers,″ in Singh I.,Squire L.&Strauss J.(eds.), Agricultural Household Models:Extensions,Applications, and Policy, Baltimore:Johns Hopkins University Press, 1986, pp.153-165. [17] 国家统计局: 《2014年全国农民工监测调查报告》, 2015年4月29日, http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/zxfb/201504/t20150429_797821.html, 2015年5月6日. [National Bureau of Statistics of the People’s Republic of China,″Surveys and Monitoring Reports on National Migrant Workers in 2014,″2015-04-29, in 2014,″ 2015-04-29, http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/zxfb/201504/t20150429_797821.html 2015-05-06.] [18] 佚名:《全国土地流转面积达3.1亿亩农民收入增长9.6%》, 2013《全国土地流转面积达3.1亿亩农民收入增长9.6%》, 2013年12月7日, http://news.xinhuanet.com/2013-12/07/c_125822569.htm 2015年5月6日. [Anon.,.,″National Land Circulation Reached 310 Million Acres, Farmers' Income Increased by 9.6%,″ 2013-12-07,http://news.xinhuanet.com/2013-12/07/c_125822569.htm, 2015-05-06.] [19] Ji Y.Q., Yu X.H. & Zhong F.N.,″Machinery Investment Decision and Off-farm Employment in Rural China,″ China Economic Review,Vol.23, No1(2012), pp.71-80. [20] Zhao Y.,″ Leaving the Countryside: Rural-to-urban Migration Decisions in China,″ The American Economic Review,Vol.89, No2(1999), pp.281-286. [21] 黄祖辉、王建英、陈志钢: 《非农就业、土地流转与土地细碎化对稻农技术效率的影响》,《中国农村经济》2014年第11期,第4-15页. [Huang Zuhui, Wang Jianying & Chen K.Z.,″Impacts of Off-farm Employment, Land Rental and Fragmentation of Farmland on Technical Efficiency of Paddy Rice Farmers,″Chinese Rural Economy, No.11(2014), pp.4-15.] [22] Cameron A.C. & Trivedi P.K., Microeconometrics: Methods and Applications, Oxford: Cambridge University Press, 2005. [24] Cappellari L.& Jenkins S.P.,″Multivariate Probit Regression Using Simulated Maximum Likelihood,″ The Stata Journal,Vol.3, No3(2003), pp.278-294.